Eye for an Eye

New details are always welcome in unsolved cases, but for the high profile cases we cover- nothing shakes the earth like a confession! Join Matt and Lisa as we revisit the latest d...

Eye for an Eye returns with our ‘Through the Looking Glass’ series of interviews with a returning favorite. Casey Sherman rejoins Lisa, and Matt for a breakdown of the book that ma...

Some cases challenge us because the outcome isn’t what we anticipated. Others have so many twists and turns, we have to keep our thoughts straight to discuss them. And some cases a...

Back in Blue: Eye for an Eye revisits one of our all time favorite guests. We loved her interview so much the first time, we needed a part two. Maureen Bogatay, 20 year veteran of ...

Ready for a laugh? In this episode of WTH3, we dive into the hilarious escapades of a man who took avoiding the check to a whole new level! Join us from the PA Turnpike as we recou...

BREAKING NEWS: A CONFESSION! Join your hosts Lisa, Matt, and our special guest Jon as we traverse the PA Turnpike and discuss further one of the most puzzling and mystifying Blind ...

Tragedy begets tragedy; in some cases far more impactfully than others. Join Matt and Lisa as we delve into a serial killer’s only surviving victim…who later would be accused of sh...

Join Matt, Jules and Lisa as delve into the complex and controversial life of Stanley "Tookie" Williams. From his early years as a co-founder of the Crips, one of the most notoriou...

Welcome back to Season 4 Eye for an Eye family! Join us for an electrifying episode as we sit down with bestselling author Casey Sherman. Known for his gripping narratives and mast...

In this gripping episode, we delve deep into the chilling case of Aileen Wuornos, one of America's most infamous female serial killers. Known as the "Damsel of Death," Wuornos' tra...

Join Jules, Lisa and Matt on a thought-provoking and chilling journey as we explore the evidence, scrutinize the theories, and question the verdict that has left many perplexed and...

In our new series, Through the Looking Glass we will be interviewing the top minds in the true crime game- from criminal profilers, investigators, police officers, homicide detecti...